Dumped by My Publisher (and the silver-lined silver lining)

Silver-Lined Silver Lining

A story of inspiration

I signed with a small press to release my first children’s novel. I’d been waiting for this moment since I was seven years old. I’d toiled for a year on this manuscript. And I was rejected 98 times out of the 150 agents I queried. But then, I got the contract.

Caveat emptor – the buyer beware

The contract seemed to lean in favor of the publisher, but what did I know? Immediately, I contacted Linda Bernfeld for advice. After sharing some of the red flags with me, she sent me to the SCBWI website to download a resource tool: THE BOOK – the Essential Guide to Publishing for Children. I spent the next four days dissecting the contract by:

  • Requesting additions — The contract lacked detailed marketing plans, a clause for the author to get out, and a clear description of what ‘the next work’ meant.
  • Requiring deletions — I couldn’t sign the contract unless clauses demanding the author cover the costs upon termination or phrases such as ‘in perpetuity’ or ‘now known or hereafter devised’ weren’t removed first.
  • Suggesting changes — I suggested ‘exclusive rights’ become ‘first option’ and ‘full-term of copyright’ change to ‘twenty years’ based off THE BOOKs suggestions.

I pulled my hair out trying to understand the contract’s every word. And when I finally did, I presented my terms to the publisher and was told, “This is an industry standard, non-negotiable contract.” So what did I do? Did I take the deal anyway? After all, what if I didn’t get another one? I couldn’t sign the contract, not after everything I had learned. I politely declined, then spent two days crying. Until the owner of the publishing house called.

A bad contract coated in honey is just a sticky, bad contract

The owner said she’d meet my terms, and she hit nearly 90 percent. After my attorney gave the okay, I signed the contract, and the honeymoon began. The cover was revealed. The proofs were mailed. Press releases were sent. It was a dream come true. One Sunday, my pastor mentioned the desire to build a new church. They would need 100K to build the new facility. I felt a stirring in my heart and talked with my pastor. I told him I was going to sell one-million books so I could tithe my ten percent, or 100K, to build this new church. I planted a faith seed that day with my pastor as my witness, and expected big things. But three weeks before my release, the owner experienced a personal tragedy in her life and disappeared from the grid. What did I do?

  • Reviews — I sent books to mommy bloggers nationwide for reviews & giveaways
  • Promotion — I submitted and published to Writer’s Digest online
  • Selling — I sold class copies to two schools
  • Buzz building — I tried creating buzz by bombarding my social media sites

The owner returned a few days before the release. Nothing had been done in her absence. She had to get a full-time job to make ends meet. And my first weeks sales came in at two books sold…yes, two! She said that it was normal because they were slow and financially struggling after her tragedy. I was told they could no longer afford to market the book, including the 150 blog tours I was guaranteed and the personal publicist. How was I supposed to sell a million books? I had forgotten that when you give something to God, forces rise up against you. But when you give something to God by faith, He always returns on the investment. I took out my contract to see what rights I had in the situation, and discovered that the publisher was in breach…big time!

A stitch in time saves mine

I learned several things right away:

  • The exact places my book should’ve been submitted for review
  • A list of events I should have been appearing at
  • The marketing tools I should have been provided with

I emailed the owner requesting a paper trail of her marketing efforts, copies of the reviews she’d received, email requests for the appearances she’d arraigned, and asked for reimbursement for the over two-grand in marketing tools I’d personally spent. Her response? She telephoned and said she was releasing me from my contract. Which told me there was no paper trail. She went on to officially void my contract, yet the next day released an audio book version of my book on Amazon, without a contract between me and the cover artist. My attorney became involved once again, and a cease and desist order was sent out. Unfortunately, the audio book is still active and I’m working on getting it removed. I HAVE NO AFFILIATION WITH THE AUDIO BOOK, so please don’t judge me if you’ve listened to a sample.

And the point of the story is…

If I hadn’t received direction and resources from the SCBWI, I would be stuck in a bum contract without ownership of any of my rights. Sure, I could sue for the many breaches, but for what? I own my rights again, I have possession of the formatted files, and I now get 100 percent of royalties for doing 100 percent of the marketing. I have to believe God has a plan which is much greater than anything I could have expected if I had stayed with the publisher. And the funny part is the theme to Clifton Chase and the Arrow of Light is that there is a power greater than us orchestrating our lives.

Would I have done things differently? I don’t know. I feel very blessed that everything worked out as smoothly as it did. Sure, it’s been a major headache to go through, but I had covered all my bases by not taking the first contract that came my way, and utilizing the guild to help me negotiate the deal. And since there’s been such great buzz and reviews from the blogs I’ve submitted to, I’m self-publishing the exact same novel so I wont’ skip a beat. The best part is that someone reading this may learn a thing or two from my story that keeps them from entering into a bogus contract. And if it took my hitting this speed bump to help you out, I’d call that the silver-lined silver lining, for sure.

I gave this book to God from the beginning and I know He is in control of every aspect of it. Doors have opened for me that I could never have opened on my own. It’s been a truly amazing experience. I still have faith that I will sell enough books to be able to tithe that 100K to my church. Why? Because God provides my needs and meets me where I’m at when I take a leap of faith. Has this ever happened to you? I would love to hear your stories of how God has taken a disaster in your life and turned it around to glorify Him. Feel free to leave those in the comment box below.

Happy Writing!

Dumped by My Publisher (and the silver-lined silver lining)

12 thoughts on “Dumped by My Publisher (and the silver-lined silver lining)

  1. I’m glad you talked about this experience in your blog. It will be helpful to other writers if you can name the publisher, especially if it still exists in some form. Good luck! Your enthusiasm and focus will lead you to success.


    1. Sorry to hear you had a similar story. It isn’t fun, but I do feel like I have a better grasp on the industry and myself as a businesswoman. I definitely feel stronger and wiser, and if I can help someone else avoid this pitfall it will have been well worth it!


  2. Karen Campbell says:

    I am so sorry Jaimi! I still want to buy the book tho, is there any out there? You are very talented and determined, I have no doubts that a bigger door is going to open for you!


  3. conrad says:

    well First i want to say is Wow. It is so awesome that you recognized that it is a behind the scenes fight everyday. Epheisans 6:12 For we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world, against spiritual wickedness in high places. Not only because you discussion to tithe,but just because the Devil is an asshole, and your stand for God makes him made.I just want to encourage you to remember that God wants abundance for us and he see’s the whole picture. It will happen just on his time table not ours. Thank you for sharing your God story , what an awesome example of a woman of God you are. were can i buy a book right now. ( credit card in my hand ready to go) :):):):):)


  4. Danielle Anderson says:

    I am surprised by the number of stories involving publishers who end up doing shady deals to writers. I am starting my own media and publishing company and hearing your story makes me want to be the exception not the rule on how writers are treated! Thank you for sharing!


    1. Thanks for commenting, Danielle. There are also a tremendous amount of quality, professional publishers out there of which I’ve had the pleasure to work with. It sounds to me like you are heading in that direction. Let me know when you’re up and running and I’ll interview you on my blog to help spread the word!


  5. Wow – Jaimie your willingness to share all of this is incredible and tremendously valuable to us who hope or plan to follow in your footsteps!

    Know too that we’re behind you all the way! Not just as “another writer” but as much more: You’re a shining example – from what I know of you so far and from what I’ve read so far of Clifton Chase – of high principles, great talent, and ultra-professionalism.

    You make me very proud to be a writer – all the more significant in this age of rampant self-publishing. The cream in the biz will rise to the top and you’re already there. More and more people will find this out, too, of course.

    That said, I can’t help but see your story above as yet another cautionary tale on how the publishing houses are scrambling (and slipping) to define themselves. Technology disrupts, just as so many real estate agents fought tooth and nail (and foolishly) to keep listings under lock and key rather than compete on their skills and knowledge, modern publishing houses seem to be an anachronism, still carnivorous dinosaurs.

    I am only a student so far in this regard – I can’t contribute anything more valuable than your story above or David Laughran’s great book, “Let’s Get Digital” which includes a great amount of insight on modern publishing and makes a strong case for self-publishing.

    Someone said “the ebook is the today’s query letter,” which really seems to be the case, and has me planning to self-publish with zero effort seeking an agent or publisher when I do start publishing my own work (I ghostwrite now).

    Considering ebooks in such a way, combined with the great quality of Clifton Chase (which I think is an instant classic in a great genre) and your obvious ability to adapt, added to your existing platform, I’d say you have absolutely nothing to worry about.

    Your million books, in my opinion, are not a matter of if but when.


    1. Rodney, WOW! Thank you for such a wonderful comment. I feel honored to hear some of the compliments you gave in such a genuine manner. More than anything else, it shows me that I am on the right path and fulfilling my purpose. It isn’t about writing a book. It is a deeper and more meaningful scope to this life. If I can help you in any way as you move from ghostwriting to self-pubbed, I’d be more than thrilled to do so. Thank you again for this heartfelt comment. It means more to me than you could ever know.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s